Right so when we signed the guy, everyone was hyping him up and saying that he was great and all that.
He did look the part initially, however since returning from his injury he has certainly not looked the part. He has been very poor since then.
Maybe we were too quick to hype him up ? After all it was Lee fucking Naylor he was replacing so I suppose he looked good because of what we had had to endure in Naylor. I'm not labelling him a dud or anything like that as it's way too early for that, I just think he has been over-rated so far.
So what are everyone's thoughts on him so far ?
"When you pull on that jersey you're not just playing for a football club, you're playing for a people and a cause"
God Bless Mr Celtic
He wouldn't stand out for another SPL team and I'm sure a McGeady or Maloney would love to play against him. That says it all about his defending.
He looks more tidy on the ball than Naylor and is more consistant with his crossing. However he is one pace and there are a good few examples in our own shitty league that are better so I'd say he's been a poor signing so far.
I think he played his one and only game for Scotland today.
An improvement from Naylor, hence why everyone loved him.
However I am an improvement from Naylor.
Been a good signing.
Hate how reliant he is on his left foot though, there's times where he's under pressure and can clear it with his right, but he'll insist on trying to get it onto his left and fuck it up somehow.
I like him playing in a piss poor defence though, his defense ain't the best but naylors was shocking, attacking wise i feel he helps mcgeady, giving a chance I think he will only get better.
One mans Terrorist is another mans Freedom Fighter!
I agree in general he's a vast improvement on Naylor. And tbh he looks a decent answer to our troubled LB slot. His delivery at times is better than McGeady / Maloney and just now anybody is gonna look awkward in defence in that back 4 just now. He's still pretty young as well so maybe due a wee bit of time.
he has been like the rest of the team so far! poor. but he is a good player and like the team he will pick up again and get better.
god will have the final say,when your day of judgment comes!
looks alright going forward, but defending seems to be a problem for him.
The whole defence needs sorting out.
10x better than Naylor.
Yes he is better than Naylor.
But that doesn’t make him a good player. I think he’s been decent. A steady performer, nothing great.
But then again, what should we expect when we are resigned to mediocre Championship players.
“If he wants to learn about scoring goals, he should nip over to watch us train at Lennoxtown some afternoon and I'll show him a thing or two about finishing”
Bookmarks