Re: Scott Brown out until February
I still rate Brown, think he's a great player.
★
Re: Scott Brown out until February
Originally Posted by Max Raptor
lol
Good cop and bad cop have left for the day :
i'm a different kind of cop !
Vic Mackey
The Shield 2003
Re: Scott Brown out until February
I would explain to you why... about his injury... about how Mogga plays him deeper than usual... the lack of a regular partner... but I'm not going to waste time forming a post to have the response of:lol
"he is SHITE"
★
Re: Scott Brown out until February
I agree Max Raptor. A fit Brown is a great SPL midfielder. We need a Nakamura type beside him though as well as Crosas. N'Guemo is a poor mans Brown so far but could learn i suppose.
Re: Scott Brown out until February
gives the ball away constantly,I would explain to you why... about his injury... about how Mogga plays him deeper than usual... the lack of a regular partner... but I'm not going to waste time forming a post to have the response of:
"he is SHITE
easily shrugged off the ball,
cant shoot
cant pass
growls at every opposing player
contributes nothing else
Good cop and bad cop have left for the day :
i'm a different kind of cop !
Vic Mackey
The Shield 2003
Re: Scott Brown out until February
If you convert that into a proper paragraph I will genuinely reply.
That's because if I reply to a list of bullet points, the next post is inevitably going to be these copied and pasted again.
★
Re: Scott Brown out until February
hopefully that ki guy is good, Zhi i think could come good and I wouldn't mind seeing the anaemic get a few games when we're more comforable in the league
Re: Scott Brown out until February
Agreed
I think he's tougher than you give him credit foreasily shrugged off the ball,
Don't think he's ever been given license to get forward to do thatcant shoot
Agreed, been shocking as of late.cant pass
There's nobody better, nothing wrong with that, imogrowls at every opposing player
I wouldn't say that, he has bags of energy, he just needs to temper it with some control.contributes nothing else
I'll admit, I wanted rid of him, but I had no idea his injury was so bad, maybe he has been struggling.
He is going nowhere until at least the end of the season, lets get him fully fit and see how he fits into Mowbray's (or whoever) new look team, and then pass judgement.
And cheers Harry, the way you posted there made it easy to reply to you
"Celtic is important to me in as much as it's one of the only constants in my life over the years. I have changed and become various things but it is the one constant. Religion, friendships have come and gone, likes and dislikes have come and gone, but Celtic has remained." - Billy Connolly
Re: Scott Brown out until February
He would give the ball away far less if he was played ahead of the midfield, like he was last season when he got POTY.
★
Re: Scott Brown out until February
That's the problem, he is expected to stay back in the current set up. It doesn't suit him.
"Celtic is important to me in as much as it's one of the only constants in my life over the years. I have changed and become various things but it is the one constant. Religion, friendships have come and gone, likes and dislikes have come and gone, but Celtic has remained." - Billy Connolly
Re: Scott Brown out until February
Exactly.
Some fans think he's became a bad player over the summer. It's a combination of a few things, most noticably being played as a more defensive midfielder which has affected his game, not his ability.
He's never been able to pass particularly well, so to stick him right in the midfield was madness.
★
Re: Scott Brown out until February
Totally. Playing beside a Nakamura and a Hartley made him a better player.
This season he's played beside N'Guemo mostly who is all over the place and finds himself everywhere bar in front of the defence for the bulk of matches. On top of this he plays with 2 wingers and a Left Back always getting caught up the park.
The biggest part of his game has always been his harrying although he can make great forward runs using his pace. Both have been completely taken out of his game protecting his injury which was stupid.
Re: Scott Brown out until February
I don't really like Brown. I'd like to see a three man midfield with:
Crosas N'guemo Zhi
We Are All Georgios Samaras
Re: Scott Brown out until February
A lot of yous rate Brown and say he is really good, yet a CM can't change to playing slightly deeper? Well he won't ever make it at the top level then imo. Maybe we wouldn't expect to see top class performances if he is slightly out of position but he has been horendous, their is no excuse.
Re: Scott Brown out until February
Don't rate Crosas at all,very poor player imo
Re: Scott Brown out until February
Hope they get back fit as soon as possible, we need them no matter what people think.
Brown is a lot better than Robson, cant believe someone said we might end up with Caldwell in midfield if Robson gets injured - we might end up with Robson in midfieldCrosas has been doing well though he should start every game from now on with N'Guemo.
"What these players have to realise, is that when you put on the Celtic jersey you're not playing for a football team, you're playing for a community and a cause"
Re: Scott Brown out until February
Robson is doing ok, so i aint losing sleep over this one.
Re: Scott Brown out until February
Robson offers more than Brown imo. He's a better passer, he's a lot better at shooting and he's much better at set pieces. He also gets stuck in just like Brown but he has more discipline than Brown. Broon has a lot of energy but runs around like a headless chicken yet gets praised for that :confused: Bizzare.
The only thing Robbo has against him is that now he is getting on a bit.
"When you pull on that jersey you're not just playing for a football club, you're playing for a people and a cause"
God Bless Mr Celtic
Re: Scott Brown out until February
I agree Ryan, Brown goes missing quite alot too.
Re: Scott Brown out until February
If TM is going to bring in players in Jan it would now look like Aiden, Artur or Skippy are the only real sellable assets...........
Posting Permissions
LinkBack URL
About LinkBacks
Quote
Bookmarks