Thread: Scott McDonald

McDonald is better than Boyd.

However, I rate neither of them.

We should keep him until the summer at least. His goals will be vital for the remainder of this season if we are to win the league.

I voted for both by accident.

I think we'll keep him though.

We will keep him. I hope.

I don't just think we should keep him, i think we need to keep him. No McDonald, no goals, no title.

I also think he will stay. All this talk of him leaving is media riddled bullshit.

He verbally abused Mowbray? Where the hell is this coming from? Just because the top scorer didn't start a big match doesn't atuomatically equal dressing room bust up. It's tactics. McDonald has said he wants to stay and i fully expect him to, for the time being at least.

I think we'll sell him, but i'd prefer for him to stay

I'd prefer him to stay in case the new striker doesn't hit the ground running, plus he'd make a pretty handy impact player.

Keep him untill the end of the season.

Also something to consider is if we keep him and get a new striker in, he may up his game as a reaction.

Originally Posted by Steven

I'd sell him, his work ethic is shockingly bad, his attitude is bad, and if it's true that he's arguing with the manager, it's time for him to go.

He's not fit to wear the no7 jersey.

If we got anywhere near £5 million for him, that would be a tremendous bit of business from Celtic.

Bye Bye league title...

Originally Posted by CE

If he leaves I won't be back at Celtic Park till Mowbray is gone. Disgrace that the only player we have that can score goals is in this position. How many times has he won us points? And the times when he has lost us them aren't that high and even then its because we are always relying on him. People look at him for the goals not Sammy etc. He has played without a consistent and good partner for years and still goes on.

Out of shape? Probably
Huffy? Not as much as some think but yes.
Passionate? Yes
Goal Scorer! YES!

Why Mowbray? If he goes it'll be down to the boards greed and prizing money over good players on the pitch.

I think he'll stay, at least til summer

We should never have sold Kenny Miller!

Whilst I’m not McDoughnut’s biggest fan. I don’t want to sell him.