Bellamy
Keane
Neither
Keane or Bellamy?
Lennon is apparently interested in making Craig our marquee siging for next season, should he get the job.
Who would you prefer?
Re: Keane or Bellamy?
Bellamy is miles ahead of Keane
Re: Keane or Bellamy?
Keane
Re: Keane or Bellamy?
Both. Nah i would take Bellers.
Re: Keane or Bellamy?
Bellamy, can make something out of nothing moreso than Keane.
Re: Keane or Bellamy?
I voted Keane, based on the fact he's one year younger than Bellamy.
Re: Keane or Bellamy?
Bellamy.
Better all round player IMO.
But Keane is a better professional.
“If he wants to learn about scoring goals, he should nip over to watch us train at Lennoxtown some afternoon and I'll show him a thing or two about finishing”
Re: Keane or Bellamy?
Bellamy is also a bit more "fragile", injuries have really hamppered his career (still had a good one though). The guy still has some crazy arse pace.
Interesting (or not) story that has surfaced is that Bellamy wants out of City. He's still not happy about the Hughes firing and he hasn't exactly seen eye to eye with Mancini. It appears that good old 'Arry will try and bring Bellamy to Spurs (wouldn't be the first time) "Arry has been a lond standing fan of the wee man. This might leave Keave as surplus to the Spurs plan. Maybe this is where Celtic come in (as does Aston Villa and probably a few other clubs)
Re: Keane or Bellamy?
There is no chance we’ll see Bellers back at Celtic.
There is more hope of keeping Keane and even that looks unlikely.
“If he wants to learn about scoring goals, he should nip over to watch us train at Lennoxtown some afternoon and I'll show him a thing or two about finishing”
Re: Keane or Bellamy?
I also love Bellamy attitude:
http://www.newsoftheworld.co.uk/spor...LLOW-PROS.html
Re: Keane or Bellamy?
yep, bellamy is going to spursOriginally Posted by RK
It's not the creed or nationality that counts, it's the man himself
Celtic - more than just a club
1312
Re: Keane or Bellamy?
Keane
leadership qualities are much better
doesn't rely on pace so much, when bellamys fucked at 31 keanes qualities remain
Bellamy cant score at the same rate as keane
Bellamy is injury prone
keanes a year younger
Keanes wages are 15k cheaper
My reasoning right there
Re: Keane or Bellamy?
Really tough choice. Bellamy is a lot better as he's proving down South but has had his fair share of injury problems.
Having both in the SPL would be magical.
Re: Keane or Bellamy?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7vv2zXBuFc8
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1TCjL5iCu24
hah holy shit B67 made that Keane one
Re: Keane or Bellamy?
Keane is a far better finisher and can work well enough on his own. Bellamy does not and cannot play on his own, which is why he failed so badly at Liverpool.
Bellamy is quicker, probably has a better overall game than Keane, but he wont score nearly as many goals, Keane is one of the best finishers there are.
Bellamy is also very injury prone, he doesnt play every match because his knees are going, got the pace but the slightest nudge and hes off sometimes.
Last edited by Jamesy; 07-05-2010 at 05:55 PM.
Re: Keane or Bellamy?
even though Bells had scored more goals than Keane in the EPL before Keane moved here. Bellamy would score tons in the SPL on his current form.
Re: Keane or Bellamy?
Keane has proven himself already and as far as im concerned i would start to build a good team around players who have proven themselves.It would be nice to have both though!
Re: Keane or Bellamy?
How many did they score each and how many appearances?
Under Hughes, Bellamy was on the left of a 433 set up. Under Mancini Bellamy hasnt scored very often, completely different way of playing now and almost purely a winger under him.
Re: Keane or Bellamy?
Keane 29 apps and 11 goals
Bellamy 33 apps 12 goals
:o
Re: Keane or Bellamy?
Keane.
Posting Permissions
LinkBack URL
About LinkBacks
Quote
Bookmarks