Thread: Kevin Kilbane

http://www.newsoftheworld.co.uk/scot...-Parkhead.html

He's a bit past it is he not ?

Yeah he's been past it for a good few years now. I can't really see any truth in it anyway.

Always liked big Kev, a bit like Barry Robson, only a little better imo. Always gives 100%. Would love to skelp the huns.

Would add good experience to the squad but i wouldnt pay lots of money for him, people could learn off him but i would only play him at left back if fox isnt fit better than naylor

Originally Posted by Dusty Mac

Always liked big Kev, a bit like Barry Robson, only a little better imo. Always gives 100%. Would love to skelp the huns.

robbo's far better IMO, different players anyway. normally i dont like old players coming to parkhead but given our options at LB i'd welcome this

no thanks, maybe a few years ago but he's past his best now. Saying that though, if he can play LB then he can't be any worse than naylor or fox

Originally Posted by Stagger Lee

no thanks, maybe a few years ago but he's past his best now. Saying that though, if he can play LB then he can't be any worse than naylor or fox

he's been a full time left back for a few years now stag, and as you say better than what we have.

Originally Posted by clagan

he's been a full time left back for a few years now stag, and as you say better than what we have.

get the bhoy signed up then! It is the news of the screws mind you , so probably fuck all in it

No no no, i laughed at hull for getting this guy, I really do not want him.

There's no point just getting a stop gap LB, we need a proper replacement so we don't have this problem again for a while.

Originally Posted by Hoopymo

No no no, i laughed at hull for getting this guy, I really do not want him.

There's no point just getting a stop gap LB, we need a proper replacement so we don't have this problem again for a while.

he's a proven international with 100 caps. he's got the experience and is better than what we have. i'd like to see a more permenant signing but it aint going to happen this transfer window

Originally Posted by clagan

he's a proven international with 100 caps. he's got the experience and is better than what we have. i'd like to see a more permenant signing but it aint going to happen this transfer window

Yeah but Ireland isn't exactly bursting with LB's and hasn't really had a decent LB since Ian Harte so his international experience means nothing to me (also david healy factor) at club level he's never impressed me really and even when he signed for hull I thought he was past it.

Originally Posted by Hoopymo

Yeah but Ireland isn't exactly bursting with LB's and hasn't really had a decent LB since Ian Harte so his international experience means nothing to me (also david healy factor) at club level he's never impressed me really and even when he signed for hull I thought he was past it.

admittedly most of his caps were at LM before he lost his pace and moved back but he's vastly experienced and i genuinely believe he's a better option than what we have.

trust me he's not the sort of player i dream of seeing at parkhead but i'd take him for 5 months

Just popped up again:

http://www.herald.ie/sport/soccer/ce...e-2031936.html

Doesn't tell us anything we don't already know though

Originally Posted by CelticInMySoul

No way do I want Kevin Kilbane at Celtic. He's a journeyman player and nothing more.

We should be going after Lee Wallace. He's young, he's Scottish and he's better than Kilbane.

What difference does that make? I would also prefer Wallace to Kilbane, but I don't care what nationality he is, only that he is a better option than Kilbane.

Originally Posted by CelticInMySoul

He knows what Scottish football is all about and I think it is important to have a few Scottish players in the squad.

especially as scottish fitba is in such a healthy state atm